Nathan v. Alamo Heights ISD
Certiorari petition pendingNathan is the Texas merits decision. The en banc Fifth Circuit rejected the federal constitutional claims; families then requested Supreme Court review. The docket records a pending petition and an October 28 response deadline, not an agreement to hear the case.
Next: 2026-10-28 — response due after extension
Docket, parties, relief and scope
- Dockets
- W.D. Tex. 5:25-cv-00756; Fifth Circuit 25-50695; Supreme Court 26-257
- Court
- Fifth Circuit / U.S. Supreme Court
- State / challenged law
- Texas / Texas SB 10
- Parties
- Parents and children v. school districts; Texas intervened. Joint certiorari petition also covers Cribbs Ringer v. Comal ISD.
- Claims
- Establishment Clause and Free Exercise Clause; parents’ direction of religious upbringing and children’s religious freedom
- Filed
- 2025-07-02 (Nathan; petition’s procedural history)
- Current posture
- April 21 en banc merits judgment reversed district judgment, vacated preliminary injunction and rendered dismissal; petition seeks review
- Preliminary relief
- Granted August 20, 2025; vacated April 21, 2026
- Permanent relief
- No permanent injunction identified in reviewed record
- Appeal
- En banc disposition April 21; related Cribbs Ringer judgment May 29 included in joint petition
- Supreme Court
- Petition filed August 17; docketed August 27, 2026; no certiorari grant recorded
- Latest filing / event
- 2026-09-28 — Professors Mark Storslee et al. amicus brief listed on Supreme Court docket
- Next known deadline
- 2026-10-28 — response due after extension
- Legal / geographic scope
- Nathan appellate judgment resolves the litigated federal claims. Fifth Circuit precedent is not a Supreme Court ruling of nationwide validity and does not decide the separate Roth state-law claims.
- Last verified
- 2026-10-09