{ "baseline": "2026-10-09", "sources": { "law": { "title": "Texas SB 13, enrolled text", "url": "https://capitol.texas.gov/tlodocs/89R/billtext/html/SB00013F.htm", "date": "2025-06-20", "note": "Primary authority; Education Code §§33.020–33.027 and transition sections.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "history": { "title": "Texas Legislature: SB 13 history", "url": "https://capitol.texas.gov/BillLookup/History.aspx?LegSess=89R&Bill=SB13", "date": "2025-06-20", "note": "Governor signed June 20; effective September 1, 2025.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "tea": { "title": "TEA implementation letter", "url": "https://tea.texas.gov/taa-letters/senate-bill-13-requirements-related-school-library-materials", "date": "2025-08-28", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "standards": { "title": "TSLAC school-library collection standards", "url": "https://www.tsl.texas.gov/ldn/schoollibrarystandards", "date": "2026-06-08", "note": "Current agency landing page.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "rules": { "title": "Texas Register: adopted library collection standards", "url": "https://www.sos.texas.gov/texreg/archive/March62026/Adopted%20Rules/13.CULTURAL%20RESOURCES.html", "date": "2026-03-06", "note": "Final rule effective March 10, 2026.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "faq": { "title": "TSLAC 2026 standards FAQ", "url": "https://www.tsl.texas.gov/sites/default/files/public/tslac/ld/schoollibs/2026%20LDN%20School%20Library%20Standards%20Guidance%20-%20FAQ.pdf", "date": "2026-05", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-library": { "title": "NBISD Library Services", "url": "https://nbisd.org/departments/library-services/", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "No planned purchases displayed at check; September 2026 list appears under approved lists.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-policy": { "title": "NBISD September 2025 board brief", "url": "https://nbisd.org/news/board-briefs-september-2025/", "date": "2025-09-09", "note": "Reports EFB(LOCAL) approval on August 11, 2025.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-challenge": { "title": "NBISD Library Materials Challenge Process", "url": "https://nbisd.org/about-nbisd/library-materials-challenge-process/", "date": "2026-09-16", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-register": { "title": "NBISD formal challenge decisions register", "url": "https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1_6MiLnoET9LT7Jk5x9-j-xmRwqQjANK97TXGveeznQM/edit?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated live register", "note": "Committee report dates are not board vote dates.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-review": { "title": "NBISD administrative review results", "url": "https://nbisd.org/library-materials-under-review/", "date": "2026-05-26", "note": "Administrative designations and separate librarian removals; not a list of board votes.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-close": { "title": "NBISD SB 13 implementation update", "url": "https://nbisd.org/news/sb13-update/", "date": "2025-10-14", "note": "October 13 board action.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-reopen": { "title": "NBISD secondary libraries reopening", "url": "https://nbisd.org/news/secondary-campus-libraries-to-reopen/", "date": "2025-10-23 board action", "note": "October 23 vote; October 27 reopening.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-march": { "title": "NBISD March 2026 board brief", "url": "https://nbisd.org/news/board-briefs-march-2026/", "date": "2026-03", "note": "Describes administrative review; publication-day precision not retained.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-form": { "title": "NBISD library materials challenge form", "url": "https://nbisd.org/wp-content/uploads/2026/10/Library-Materials-Challenge-Form-261001.pdf", "date": "2026-10-01", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "nb-acq": { "title": "NBISD September 2026 approved list", "url": "https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1qm6mm4Vwwdz6QPgsR6F5GvIuapovUIU5jOE4Au2BBBw/edit?usp=sharing", "date": "2026-09", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "conroe": { "title": "Conroe ISD Library Services", "url": "https://www.conroeisd.net/o/cisd/page/library-services/", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "conroe-policy": { "title": "Conroe ISD EFB policy portal", "url": "https://policyconnect.org/policy/conroe-isd/EFB", "date": "Undated", "note": "District-linked portal; text/adoption date could not be independently extracted in this audit.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "conroe-register": { "title": "Conroe ISD formal reconsideration determinations", "url": "https://docs.google.com/document/d/1JIBb360PTaJaNQNuzL1oLkInQepRdC4l3LTH53u1ONs/edit?usp=sharing", "date": "2026-09-11", "note": "Contains month-level decision dates and pending September reviews.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "conroe-parent": { "title": "Conroe parent restriction form", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1lbN2iZCBcXKlmY5XYC6zqQmpC7Y_fo2U/view?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "conroe-form": { "title": "Conroe reconsideration form", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/11d4l6yLwAsItAllYhycGrTvw6cEh9BDW/view?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf": { "title": "CFISD Library Resources", "url": "https://www.cfisd.net/academics/cfisd-libraries", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-policy": { "title": "CFISD EFB(LOCAL) linked PDF", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1758544469/cfisdnet/qspqkkp8rsjyvvmmzysq/EFBLOCAL2025.pdf", "date": "Undated retrieved PDF", "note": "Search index shows 8 pages/adopted August 11, 2025; direct retrieval returned 9 pages with blank adoption fields. Current-version/adoption conflict unresolved.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-register": { "title": "CFISD formal reconsideration register", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1791490629/cfisdnet/t61npalllimeivlq2k5t/WEBSITE42823.pdf", "date": "2022–2023 events; document undated", "note": "Historical committee outcomes; current campus holdings not verified. One Flamer row says December 15, 2023 within 2022–23 school-year section.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-parents": { "title": "CFISD Destiny parental controls", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Ein4-411k1lBipCQ9N4cttTIgHdq6NBJ/view?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-sora": { "title": "CFISD Sora parental controls", "url": "https://drive.google.com/file/d/1RWgeOUo6LDBQOK-7F6lb0iIZBeRdoKXS/view?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-committee": { "title": "CFISD Library Reconsideration Committee", "url": "https://www.cfisd.net/our-district/committees/library-reconsideration-committee", "date": "2026-10-02 application deadline", "note": "Reconsideration committee is not evidence of a statutory advisory council.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "cf-acq": { "title": "CFISD dated acquisition posting", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1757105625/cfisdnet/rcu7myog39cgpqd5kvoa/9525ACQUISITIONLIST.pdf", "date": "2025-09-05", "note": "Historical window ended October 6, 2025.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock": { "title": "Lubbock ISD Library Media Services", "url": "https://www.lubbockisd.org/o/lisd/page/library-media-services", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "Displays September 10–October 10, 2026 acquisition comment window.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-parent": { "title": "Lubbock parent and community library guidance", "url": "https://www.lubbockisd.org/o/lisd/page/parent-and-community-library", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-controls": { "title": "Lubbock Destiny parent instructions", "url": "https://aptg.co/Mjg5G1", "date": "Undated PDF", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-council": { "title": "Lubbock School Library Advisory Council", "url": "https://www.lubbockisd.org/o/lisd/page/slac", "date": "2026-10-19 scheduled meeting", "note": "Future meeting listed as of October 9; not an event already held.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-register": { "title": "Lubbock challenged-title register", "url": "https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/14gs4JDb2Iz168QT9TBIVFHsVkMKfCwujW8FhNvCCdLw/edit?usp=sharing", "date": "Undated live register", "note": "Nine pending titles; resolved-section heading says board voted while many action cells still say In committee.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-minutes": { "title": "Lubbock SLAC May 13 meeting minutes", "url": "https://aptg.co/78D9c6", "date": "2026-05-13", "note": "Recommendations only; does not establish final board disposition.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-acq": { "title": "Lubbock proposed acquisition list", "url": "https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/10fHjxBjmqDF5kCflBlC1Yh-NLXTRvhjtDWVfhGsat8Q/edit?usp=sharing", "date": "2026-09-10 window start", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-appeal": { "title": "Lubbock August 19 appeal meeting agenda", "url": "https://meetings.boardbook.org/Public/Agenda/869?meeting=760936", "date": "2026-08-19", "note": "Agenda establishes scheduled consideration, not a vote or final outcome.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw": { "title": "Fort Worth ISD Library Media Services", "url": "https://www.fwisd.org/departments/library-media-services", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw-council": { "title": "Fort Worth ISD SLAC records and acquisition lists", "url": "https://www.fwisd.org/departments/library-media-services/slac", "date": "2026-08-20 latest listed minutes", "note": "Rosters, agendas, minutes and recordings; current acquisition list labels can change.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw-minutes": { "title": "Fort Worth SLAC March 5 minutes", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1774637290/fwisdorg/r5szpgzx4f5ax8s46wwf/SLACMarch52026MeetingMinutes.pdf", "date": "2026-03-05", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw-appointments": { "title": "Fort Worth October 28 board recap", "url": "https://www.fwisd.org/board/board-brief-meeting-recap/~board/board-meeting-recap-board-of-education-109365/post/fort-worth-isd-board-brief-oct-28-2025", "date": "2025-10-28", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw-catalog": { "title": "Fort Worth school-library catalogs", "url": "https://www.fwisd.org/departments/library-media-services/school-library-catalogs", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "fw-challenge": { "title": "Fort Worth requests for reconsideration", "url": "https://www.fwisd.org/departments/library-media-services/requests-for-reconsideration", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "ysleta": { "title": "Ysleta SB 13 Library Materials", "url": "https://www.yisd.net/page/sb-13-library-materials", "date": "Undated live page", "note": "Reports August 27, 2025 EFB(LOCAL) approval; TLC parent engagement still labeled coming soon.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "ysleta-acq": { "title": "Ysleta proposed library purchases", "url": "https://www.yisd.net/o/yisd/page/proposed-book-purchases-for-library", "date": "2026-03", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lake": { "title": "Lake Dallas School Library Advisory Council", "url": "https://www.ldisd.net/departments/curriculum-instruction/school-library-advisory-council", "date": "2026-03-03 agenda", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "heb": { "title": "HEB ISD library-materials website announcement", "url": "https://www.hebisd.edu/post-details/~board/hebisd-news/post/new-library-materials-website-sb-13", "date": "2025-10-27", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "stockton": { "title": "Fort Stockton library transparency", "url": "https://www.fsisd.net/departments/library/library-transparency", "date": "2026-05-26 approved list", "note": "Local summary simplifies the state board-action timetable; use enacted law for exact rule.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "spring": { "title": "Spring Branch EFB(EXHIBIT) challenge procedure", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1763676450/springbranchisdcom/gr7ji9pfeqmom73tcnut/EFBEXHIBIT112025.pdf", "date": "2025-11-10", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "dallas": { "title": "Dallas selection policies and procedures", "url": "https://www.dallasisd.org/departments/library-media-services/selection-policies-procedures", "date": "Undated", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "dallas-reg": { "title": "Dallas EFB(REGULATION) amendment notice", "url": "https://www.dallasisd.org/board-of-trustees/board-policy-and-procedures/policy-alerts/policy-alert-viewer/~board/dallas-isd-policy-alerts/post/recently-amended-efb-regulation-august-23-2025", "date": "2025-08-23", "note": "Administrative regulation approval; not a trustee adoption vote.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "katy": { "title": "Katy instructional resources information", "url": "https://www.katyisd.org/instructional-resources-information", "date": "Undated", "note": "Procedures include earlier parent notification program; latest SB 13 board action not verified.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "plano": { "title": "Plano SLAC meeting agenda", "url": "https://resources.finalsite.net/images/v1759782449/pisdedu/wbbdfnbnybn4z9inxzal/PlanoISDSLACmeetingAgenda.pdf", "date": "2025-10", "note": "Agenda alone does not establish later decisions.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "leander": { "title": "Leander 2025–26 student handbook", "url": "https://www.leanderisd.org/wp-content/uploads/2025/08/2025-2026-Student-Handbook-1.pdf", "date": "2025-08", "note": "Prior school-year source; current version not reverified.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "frisco": { "title": "Frisco student handbook", "url": "https://www.friscoisd.org/docs/default-source/resources-information/frisco-isd-student-handbook.pdf?sfvrsn=8", "date": "2025–2026 edition reviewed", "note": "", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "austin": { "title": "Austin board bulletin on SB 13", "url": "https://www.austinisd.org/announcements/2025/08/26/board-bulletin-trustees-review-early-literacy-gains-school-consolidation", "date": "2025-08-26", "note": "Implementation briefing; not final policy adoption.", "verified": "2026-10-09" }, "lubbock-policy": { "title": "Lubbock August 28, 2025 policy agenda", "url": "https://manuals.boardbook.org/Public/Agenda/869?meeting=705401", "date": "2025-08-28", "verified": "2026-10-09", "note": "EFB(LOCAL) title and proposed adoption item; agenda does not prove adoption." } }, "districts": [ { "id": "new-braunfels-isd", "district": "New Braunfels ISD", "county": "Comal", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 1, "published": true, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Instructional Materials – Library Materials (EFB LOCAL), as named in the September board brief", "policyEvidence": "Adoption documented", "acquisitionAdopted": "Documented", "adoptionDate": "2025-08-11", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Documented", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Other committee documented", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Documented", "latestSourceDate": "2026-10-01", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "nb-library", "nb-policy", "nb-challenge", "nb-register", "nb-review", "nb-close", "nb-reopen", "nb-march", "nb-form", "nb-acq" ], "summary": "A documented policy adoption, administrative collection review and two formal challenge decisions make this the strongest case for separating recommendations from board action.", "catalogUrl": "https://nbisd.follettdestiny.com/common/welcome.jsp?context=saas124_4265372", "parentSteps": "Open Library Services and its Destiny catalog/parent instructions. The district describes access to current and historical checkouts and the ability to restrict individual titles for a linked child. Use its separate Sora instructions for digital materials; a print-catalog restriction should not be assumed to change Sora. Contact the campus librarian if the parent account is not linked.", "controls": "Destiny offers title restrictions. Sora serves grades 6–12, with young-adult access described for grades 8–12 and different access for grades 6–7. The district provides separate Sora parental-control instructions.", "acquisition": "The live page displayed no planned purchases at the October 9 check. Its September 2026 list was filed under board-approved acquisitions, so this tracker does not present an expired proposal as an open comment window.", "challenge": "Begin with the campus librarian or principal for informal concerns. The district directs formal submissions to the principal’s office using its challenge form. Its published review procedure uses one librarian, one teacher and three parents; the committee reads the complete work and recommends an action to trustees. Access is restricted during review. The page distinguishes formal challenges from grievances about administrative removals.", "council": "The October 2025 board-created SB 13 advisory committee and title-specific review committees are documented. A qualifying parent petition and evidence establishing a statutory §33.025 parent-majority council were not located. Those bodies should not be treated as interchangeable.", "limitations": "The formal register supplies committee report dates and separate committee/board tallies but does not give a board meeting date for either selected title. It reports actions taken; live campus-by-campus catalog holdings were not independently checked. Administrative SB 13 designations on a separate page are not trustee votes.", "timeline": [ [ "2025-08-11", "EFB(LOCAL) approved, as reported in the September board brief.", "nb-policy" ], [ "2025-10-13", "Board unanimously voted to suspend secondary library operations and create a board advisory committee.", "nb-close" ], [ "2025-10-23", "Board unanimously voted to reopen secondary libraries October 27.", "nb-reopen" ], [ "2026-04-21", "Allegedly committee report: compliant, 5–0; the register separately records a contrary 6–1 board decision.", "nb-register" ], [ "2026-06-10", "Barbie Today committee report: compliant, 5–0; register separately records board approval, 7–0.", "nb-register" ] ], "reason": "Publish: uniquely useful committee-versus-board comparison, dated implementation sequence and practical parent controls. Strong search interest observed, without a measured volume estimate.", "publicCommentWindow": "No planned purchases displayed on October 9; September 2026 list filed as approved", "administrativeReview": "District administrative review and separate campus-librarian removals documented; do not count as board challenge decisions" }, { "id": "conroe-isd", "district": "Conroe ISD", "county": "Montgomery", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 2, "published": true, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB – Library Materials (district-linked policy portal; full current heading not independently verified)", "policyEvidence": "Policy linked", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Documented", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Documented", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "conroe", "conroe-policy", "conroe-register", "conroe-parent", "conroe-form" ], "summary": "The September 11, 2026 register identifies a removal, three restorations and five pending reviews from the SB 13 period, with decision-makers named.", "catalogUrl": "https://conroeisd.follettdestiny.com", "parentSteps": "Open the district Library Services page and choose the Destiny catalog. For classroom collections, the district directs families to Canvas or Seesaw. Ask the campus librarian for help identifying the relevant library and student record.", "controls": "The district links an English and Spanish parent restriction form for specific materials. Submit the district’s form through its campus process. Separate parent permission is described for AP/dual-credit resources outside standard library materials.", "acquisition": "Proposed titles are published by grade band for a 30-day public review before board approval. The page links a public feedback form. A displayed 2026–27 schedule also includes February, March and July dates labeled 2026; the year sequence is inconsistent and is not silently corrected here. Confirm a particular deadline with the district.", "challenge": "The district links formal reconsideration instructions and a form. Its decision register distinguishes the review body and the final determination. The five September 2026 cases remain marked pending in the latest dated register; no later final order was located during this audit.", "council": "A current statutory advisory-council roster, qualifying petition and final establishment record were not located in the reviewed sources. The current EFB portal is linked by the district, but its text and adoption date could not be independently extracted.", "limitations": "The register uses month-level dates, not exact board meeting dates, and provides no vote tallies for the selected cases. A past restoration is the last recorded action, not proof of every campus’s current stock. The local page’s broad two-year statement should be read alongside §33.027(j), which addresses material the board retained.", "timeline": [ [ "2025-10", "Register attributes removal of I am Billie Jean King to the Board of Trustees.", "conroe-register" ], [ "2025-11", "Register attributes two restorations to the board.", "conroe-register" ], [ "2026-02", "Register reports restoration of The Action Bible: Heroes and Villains.", "conroe-register" ], [ "2026-09-11", "Register update lists five September cases pending review.", "conroe-register" ] ], "reason": "Publish: strongest recent named-title outcome register, including restorations often lost in aggregate removal lists; repeatable source for updates.", "publicCommentWindow": "30-day list process documented; exact current closing date not verified" }, { "id": "lubbock-isd", "district": "Lubbock ISD", "county": "Lubbock", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 3, "published": true, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(LOCAL) – Instructional Resources: Library Materials (named in district board materials)", "policyEvidence": "Policy referenced", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Documented", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Council documented", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Documented", "latestSourceDate": "2026-10-19 scheduled; observed 2026-10-09", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "lubbock", "lubbock-parent", "lubbock-controls", "lubbock-council", "lubbock-register", "lubbock-minutes", "lubbock-acq", "lubbock-appeal", "lubbock-policy" ], "summary": "A working council document archive, a currently posted acquisition window and a live challenged-title register give parents several specific ways to follow decisions.", "catalogUrl": "https://library.lubbockisd.org/", "parentSteps": "Use the Library section of the child’s campus website to enter its catalog. The parent instructions use the primary guardian email stored in Frontline to obtain a Destiny access code. Once linked, choose the child if more than one is listed, then view checkouts or search the collection.", "controls": "The parent guide explains how to use the three-dot menu on a title to block checkout, and the Blocked view to remove a block. Checkout emails go to the primary email in the student record. If access fails, first check the guardian email in registration and contact the district help desk through the instructions.", "acquisition": "The Library Media Services page lists September 10–October 10, 2026 for public comments on proposed additions. After public review, SLAC makes recommendations and the board votes. The October 19, 2026 council meeting is scheduled for 5 p.m. at the Byron Martin Advanced Technology Center, 3201 Avenue Q, Door 4; it was still a future meeting on the baseline date.", "challenge": "The parent/community page links the district challenge form. It states that challenged titles are temporarily removed from shelves and the online catalog during review, that the challenge goes to SLAC within five days, and that SLAC recommends within 90 days. This is temporary unavailability, not a final removal.", "council": "The district publishes council agendas, minutes and recordings from November 2025 through May 2026, with future dates listed. May 13 minutes document title recommendations. The council page also lists an August 19, 2026 board appeal agenda; an agenda proves scheduled consideration, not its result. A qualifying petition or certification was not located.", "limitations": "The register’s resolved-section heading describes board votes, while many rows still say In committee. For Kingdom of Ash, May minutes recommend middle/high retention while the register says high-school-only. This tracker records the discrepancy and does not invent a final vote or appeal result.", "timeline": [ [ "2025-11-18", "First council meeting listed in the current archive.", "lubbock-council" ], [ "2026-05-13", "Council recommended retaining, relocating or removing selected titles; these are recommendations.", "lubbock-minutes" ], [ "2026-08-19", "Special board appeal agenda includes Heroine and Kingdom of Ash, among others.", "lubbock-appeal" ], [ "2026-09-10 to 2026-10-10", "Posted acquisition comment window.", "lubbock" ], [ "2026-10-19 (scheduled)", "Next listed SLAC meeting; not yet held at baseline.", "lubbock-council" ] ], "reason": "Publish: current parent action window, council minutes, appeals and an explicit source conflict provide original accountability value.", "publicCommentWindow": "2026-09-10 through 2026-10-10, per live Library Media Services page" }, { "id": "cypress-fairbanks-isd", "district": "Cypress-Fairbanks ISD", "county": "Harris", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 4, "published": true, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(LOCAL) – Instructional Resources: Library Materials", "policyEvidence": "Policy text located; version conflict", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Documented", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Other committee documented", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Historical records", "latestSourceDate": "2026-10-02 application deadline", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "cf", "cf-policy", "cf-register", "cf-parents", "cf-sora", "cf-committee", "cf-acq" ], "summary": "Current parent-control instructions and a historical campus-level reconsideration register answer different questions; this tracker keeps them separate.", "catalogUrl": "https://cyfairisd.follettdestiny.com", "parentSteps": "Use Find your Campus Library on the district Library Resources page. It opens the Destiny campus list. The same district page links Destiny and Sora parent-control instructions and the CFISD parent portal.", "controls": "The live district page says parents can opt a child into higher collections or out of library services using Library Opt-In/Out in the parent portal. Specific-title restrictions are available separately in Destiny and Sora; Sora is described for grades 3–12. Use the linked instructions for each system.", "acquisition": "The policy text requires a public list for at least 30 days before trustees approve or reject new purchases or donations. A dated September 5, 2025 list documents a historical window ending October 6, 2025. A current open window was not independently confirmed.", "challenge": "The retrieved policy text begins with informal campus review, followed by a signed TEA form to the district-level library supervisor if unresolved. It describes full-work committee review and temporary access restrictions. The current parent-representative committee page lists October 2, 2026 as its application deadline, now past at baseline.", "council": "A library reconsideration committee is documented. A separate §33.025 advisory-council establishment record, roster or qualifying petition was not located. Committee recruitment alone does not establish a statutory council.", "limitations": "The policy PDF changed at a persistent URL: search indexing describes an eight-page adopted 2025 version, while direct retrieval returned nine pages with blank adoption fields. Its exact current adoption date remains unverified. Historical 2022–23 committee outcomes below are not SB 13-era board decisions or current catalog checks.", "timeline": [ [ "2022–2023", "Historical formal-request register records campus-specific committee outcomes.", "cf-register" ], [ "2025-09-05", "Acquisition proposal posted; stated comment window ended October 6, 2025.", "cf-acq" ], [ "2026-10-02", "Current parent committee application deadline.", "cf-committee" ], [ "2026-10-09", "Live parent guidance verified; policy-version conflict and historical-status limits recorded.", "cf" ] ], "reason": "Publish: substantial parent-service detail plus campus-specific historical records, with clear boundaries around adoption and current-status uncertainty.", "publicCommentWindow": "Historical: 2025-09-05 through 2025-10-06; current window not verified" }, { "id": "fort-worth-isd", "district": "Fort Worth ISD", "county": "Tarrant", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 5, "published": true, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(LOCAL) – Instructional Resources: Library Materials (identified in council minutes)", "policyEvidence": "Policy referenced", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Council documented", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2026-08-20 listed minutes", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "fw", "fw-council", "fw-minutes", "fw-appointments", "fw-catalog", "fw-challenge" ], "summary": "Fort Worth offers a useful view of the acquisition process through a council roster and recurring public meeting records, even where title-level final decisions were not located.", "catalogUrl": "https://www.fwisd.org/departments/library-media-services/school-library-catalogs", "parentSteps": "Open the district’s School Library Catalogs page, then its Library Catalog link. Use the child’s campus collection. The public catalog link is documented; access to private student checkout records was not tested.", "controls": "A specific current parent checkout-restriction workflow was not located in the reviewed district pages. Contact the campus librarian for the district’s current form or portal instructions. Texas §33.023 supplies the underlying right, but it does not prove that a particular local interface has been verified.", "acquisition": "The SLAC page publishes proposed acquisition lists and describes 30-day public feedback before recommendations and board action. March 5 minutes discuss the January 30 proposed list and the review process. A council recommendation should not be described as a board acquisition approval.", "challenge": "The Requests for Reconsideration page directs requests through board policy and links a TEA Challenge Form. The audit located the entry point, but not a complete dated public register of title-level board dispositions. Ask the district for the challenged title, committee recommendation, board order and any appeal result.", "council": "The October 28, 2025 board recap reports council appointments in the consent agenda. The current SLAC page lists board/district appointments, some vacancies, and meetings on March 5, April 16, May 21, June 18 and August 20, 2026. March minutes document organization and acquisition review. A qualifying petition was not located.", "limitations": "The council archive is strong evidence of an operating public process. It is not proof that every required notice, posting deadline or membership condition was satisfied. A standalone title-level final decision and a current restriction interface were not located.", "timeline": [ [ "2025-10-28", "Board recap records SLAC appointments.", "fw-appointments" ], [ "2026-03-05", "Council minutes document organization, EFB policy and acquisition review.", "fw-minutes" ], [ "2026-04-16 to 2026-08-20", "Additional council meetings listed with public records.", "fw-council" ], [ "2026-10-09", "Catalog, challenge entry point and council archive reviewed.", "fw" ] ], "reason": "Publish: unusually strong council and acquisition archive complements the title-decision trackers; clear limits prevent unsupported outcome claims.", "publicCommentWindow": "30-day public feedback process documented; exact current closing date not verified" }, { "id": "ysleta-isd", "district": "Ysleta ISD", "county": "El Paso", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 6, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(LOCAL) (full current heading not verified)", "policyEvidence": "Adoption documented", "acquisitionAdopted": "Documented", "adoptionDate": "2025-08-27", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Announced", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2026-03", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "ysleta", "ysleta-acq" ], "summary": "useful official SB 13 hub, catalog and acquisition links; parent engagement remains labeled coming soon, and council/title-level final records were not located.", "reason": "Hold: useful official SB 13 hub, catalog and acquisition links; parent engagement remains labeled coming soon, and council/title-level final records were not located.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "lake-dallas-isd", "district": "Lake Dallas ISD", "county": "Denton", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 7, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Not located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Council documented", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2026-03-03", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "lake" ], "summary": "council agendas/minutes support recurring coverage; acquire current parent procedures, policy adoption and final title decisions for this audit.", "reason": "Hold: council agendas/minutes support recurring coverage; acquire current parent procedures, policy adoption and final title decisions before a full tracker.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "hurst-euless-bedford-isd", "district": "Hurst-Euless-Bedford ISD", "county": "Tarrant", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 8, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Not located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Announced", "parentControls": "Announced", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Announced", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-10-27", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "heb" ], "summary": "official announcement describes catalog, checkouts, parent limits and 30-day lists; verify the live workflows and final records for this audit.", "reason": "Hold: official announcement describes catalog, checkouts, parent limits and 30-day lists; verify the live workflows and final records before a standalone page.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "fort-stockton-isd", "district": "Fort Stockton ISD", "county": "Pecos", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 9, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(LOCAL) (linked; full heading not verified)", "policyEvidence": "Policy linked", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Documented", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Documented", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2026-05-26", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "stockton" ], "summary": "useful library transparency hub and approved list; council and named final challenge decisions remain unverified. Local timing summary needs comparison with exact law.", "reason": "Hold: useful library transparency hub and approved list; council and named final challenge decisions remain unverified. Local timing summary needs comparison with exact law.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "spring-branch-isd", "district": "Spring Branch ISD", "county": "Harris", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 10, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(EXHIBIT) – Instructional Resources: Media Center Materials", "policyEvidence": "Procedure exhibit located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-11-10", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "spring" ], "summary": "current exhibit gives a formal challenge route, but a complete current parent/council/decision record set was not located during the site migration.", "reason": "Hold: current exhibit gives a formal challenge route, but a complete current parent/council/decision record set was not located during the site migration.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "dallas-isd", "district": "Dallas ISD", "county": "Dallas", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 11, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "EFB(REGULATION) – Instructional Resources: Library Media Programs", "policyEvidence": "Administrative regulation located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-08-23", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "dallas", "dallas-reg" ], "summary": "official regulation and selection procedures are useful, but administrative approval must not be counted as a board adoption vote; locate current outcomes and council records.", "reason": "Hold: official regulation and selection procedures are useful, but administrative approval must not be counted as a board adoption vote; locate current outcomes and council records.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "katy-isd", "district": "Katy ISD", "county": "Harris", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 12, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Not located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Documented", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "katy" ], "summary": "parent notification and review information is available, but the latest SB 13 adoption, council and decision records need a deeper document audit.", "reason": "Hold: parent notification and review information is available, but the latest SB 13 adoption, council and decision records need a deeper document audit.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "plano-isd", "district": "Plano ISD", "county": "Collin", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 13, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Not located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Council agenda located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-10", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "plano" ], "summary": "council agenda is a useful lead; verify current membership, meeting outcomes and parent procedures. An agenda is not proof of a later vote.", "reason": "Hold: council agenda is a useful lead; verify current membership, meeting outcomes and parent procedures. An agenda is not proof of a later vote.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "leander-isd", "district": "Leander ISD", "county": "Williamson", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 14, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Handbook reference", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Historical documentation", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-08", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "leander" ], "summary": "2025–26 handbook describes Destiny/Sora and grade-related permissions; 2026–27 procedures and current board outcomes not verified.", "reason": "Hold: 2025–26 handbook describes Destiny/Sora and grade-related permissions; 2026–27 procedures and current board outcomes not verified.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "frisco-isd", "district": "Frisco ISD", "county": "Collin", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 15, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Handbook reference", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Historical documentation", "parentControls": "Historical documentation", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025–2026 edition", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "frisco" ], "summary": "handbook explains catalogs, child-specific limits and notices, but current-year implementation and named final records need confirmation.", "reason": "Hold: handbook explains catalogs, child-specific limits and notices, but current-year implementation and named final records need confirmation.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" }, { "id": "austin-isd", "district": "Austin ISD", "county": "Travis", "countyScope": "Administrative-center county; not a complete district boundary list", "rank": 16, "published": false, "policyNumber": "EFB", "policyTitle": "Exact title not verified", "policyEvidence": "Not located", "acquisitionAdopted": "Not located", "adoptionDate": "Not located", "parentAccess": "Not located", "parentControls": "Not located", "challengeProcedure": "Not located", "councilStatus": "Not located", "petitionStatus": "Qualifying petition or certification not located", "acquisitionRecords": "Not located", "decisionRecords": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "2025-08-26", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "sources": [ "austin" ], "summary": "board bulletin documents discussion of SB 13; no final adoption or title outcome is inferred. A full current evidence bundle is still needed.", "reason": "Hold: board bulletin documents discussion of SB 13; no final adoption or title outcome is inferred. A full current evidence bundle is still needed.", "publicCommentWindow": "Not located" } ], "cases": [ { "id": "nb-allegedly", "districtId": "new-braunfels-isd", "title": "Allegedly", "author": "Tiffany D. Jackson", "challenger": "Debbie Leimbach", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "SB 13 compliant; 5–0; report dated 2026-04-21", "boardAction": "Did not approve committee recommendation; register says removed from libraries", "boardVote": "6–1", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Removed", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-04-21", "dateBasis": "Committee report date; board vote date not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The board tally is separate from the committee tally. Do not date the board vote April 21 from this register.", "sources": [ "nb-register" ] }, { "id": "nb-barbie", "districtId": "new-braunfels-isd", "title": "Barbie Today", "author": "Elizabeth Andrews", "challenger": "John Hewitt", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "SB 13 compliant; 5–0; report dated 2026-06-10", "boardAction": "Approved committee recommendation; register says placed back on shelf", "boardVote": "7–0", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Restored", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-06-10", "dateBasis": "Committee report date; board vote date not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "", "sources": [ "nb-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-billie", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "I am Billie Jean King", "author": "Brad Meltzer", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Remove from school library catalog", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "2025-10 (month only)", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Removed", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2025-10", "dateBasis": "Board decision month", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-anne", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Anne of West Philly", "author": "Ivy Noelle Weir", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Restore to school library catalog", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "2025-11 (month only)", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Restored", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2025-11", "dateBasis": "Board decision month", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-angry", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "An Angry Spirit: A Ghost Story", "author": "Anita Croy", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Restore to school library catalog", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "2025-11 (month only)", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Restored", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2025-11", "dateBasis": "Board decision month", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-bible", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "The Action Bible: Heroes and Villains", "author": "David C. Cook (credited in district register)", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Board decision", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Restore to school library catalog", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "2026-02 (month only)", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Restored", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-02", "dateBasis": "Board decision month", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The register credits David C. Cook; this may be a publisher attribution. Preserved as published.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-mercy", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Just Mercy", "author": "Bryan Stevenson", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Challenge filed", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Register says pending review; exact campus holdings not independently checked", "outcome": "Under review", "currentOutcome": "Under review", "eventDate": "2026-09", "dateBasis": "Register review month; filing day not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Review body and final determination are not identified. Pending in the September 11 register, still linked on October 9.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-persepolis", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Persepolis", "author": "Marjane Satrapi", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Challenge filed", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Register says pending review; exact campus holdings not independently checked", "outcome": "Under review", "currentOutcome": "Under review", "eventDate": "2026-09", "dateBasis": "Register review month; filing day not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Review body and final determination are not identified. Pending in the September 11 register, still linked on October 9.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-rabbit", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Rabbit Chase", "author": "Elizabeth Lapensee", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Challenge filed", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Register says pending review; exact campus holdings not independently checked", "outcome": "Under review", "currentOutcome": "Under review", "eventDate": "2026-09", "dateBasis": "Register review month; filing day not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Review body and final determination are not identified. Pending in the September 11 register, still linked on October 9.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-rainbow", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Rainbow Revolutionaries", "author": "Sarah Prager", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Challenge filed", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Register says pending review; exact campus holdings not independently checked", "outcome": "Under review", "currentOutcome": "Under review", "eventDate": "2026-09", "dateBasis": "Register review month; filing day not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Review body and final determination are not identified. Pending in the September 11 register, still linked on October 9.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "conroe-will", "districtId": "conroe-isd", "title": "Will on the Inside", "author": "Andrew Eliopulos", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Challenge filed", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Not located", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Register says pending review; exact campus holdings not independently checked", "outcome": "Under review", "currentOutcome": "Under review", "eventDate": "2026-09", "dateBasis": "Register review month; filing day not supplied", "latestSourceDate": "2026-09-11", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Review body and final determination are not identified. Pending in the September 11 register, still linked on October 9.", "sources": [ "conroe-register" ] }, { "id": "cf-roller", "districtId": "cypress-fairbanks-isd", "title": "Roller Girl", "author": "Victoria Jamieson", "challenger": "Parent (not named)", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Wells Elementary", "grades": "Elementary", "stage": "Final current status not located", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Retained in collection; register spells author Victoria Jameson", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Retained", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2022-12-15", "dateBasis": "Historical register date; date type not further specified", "latestSourceDate": "2022–2023 events; document undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Historical committee outcome, not a board vote. Current status is unknown and no SB 13 attribution is made.", "sources": [ "cf-register" ] }, { "id": "cf-fun", "districtId": "cypress-fairbanks-isd", "title": "Fun Home", "author": "Alison Bechdel", "challenger": "Community (not named)", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Cy-Fair; Cypress Lakes", "grades": "High school", "stage": "Final current status not located", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Removed from collection", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Removed", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2023-01-18", "dateBasis": "Historical register date; date type not further specified", "latestSourceDate": "2022–2023 events; document undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Historical committee outcome, not a board vote. Current status is unknown and no SB 13 attribution is made.", "sources": [ "cf-register" ] }, { "id": "cf-boys", "districtId": "cypress-fairbanks-isd", "title": "All Boys Aren't Blue", "author": "George M. Johnson", "challenger": "Community (not named)", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Cypress Woods", "grades": "11–12", "stage": "Final current status not located", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Retained in grades 11–12", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Age or grade restricted", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2022-12-16", "dateBasis": "Historical register date; date type not further specified", "latestSourceDate": "2022–2023 events; document undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Historical committee outcome, not a board vote. Current status is unknown and no SB 13 attribution is made.", "sources": [ "cf-register" ] }, { "id": "cf-magenta", "districtId": "cypress-fairbanks-isd", "title": "Beyond Magenta", "author": "Susan Kuklin", "challenger": "Community (not named)", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Dean Middle School", "grades": "8 with permission", "stage": "Final current status not located", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Retained in grade 8 with permission", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "Age or grade restricted", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2022-12-08", "dateBasis": "Historical register date; date type not further specified", "latestSourceDate": "2022–2023 events; document undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Historical committee outcome, not a board vote. Current status is unknown and no SB 13 attribution is made.", "sources": [ "cf-register" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-nineteen", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Nineteen Minutes", "author": "Jodi Picoult", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-sofia", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Sofia Valdez Future Prez", "author": "Andrea Beaty", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-best", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "The Best Man", "author": "Richard Peck", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-julie", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Julie of the Wolves", "author": "Jean Craighead George", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-blood", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Blood and Honey", "author": "Shelby Mahurin", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-thorns", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "A Court of Thorns and Roses", "author": "Sarah Maas (as listed)", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-kingdom", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Kingdom of the Cursed", "author": "Kerri Maniscalco", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-blankets", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Blankets", "author": "Craig Thompson", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-boy", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "This Boy", "author": "Lauren Myracle", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "All district libraries during review, per district procedure", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee review", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "Pending SLAC recommendation and board approval", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "District procedure says challenged titles are temporarily unavailable from shelves and online catalog pending a decision", "outcome": "Temporarily restricted", "currentOutcome": "Temporarily restricted", "eventDate": "", "dateBasis": "Not located", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "The live register supplies no received date for this row. Temporary review is not a final removal.", "sources": [ "lubbock-register", "lubbock-parent" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-ash", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "Kingdom of Ash", "author": "Sarah J. Maas", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Middle / high school", "stage": "Final current status not located", "challengeDate": "2024-03-19", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "May 13, 2026: retain in middle and high schools", "boardAction": "Register heading says trustees voted, but row still says In committee; August 19 appeal agenda located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "No final decision located", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-08-19", "dateBasis": "Appeal agenda date; result not verified", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Register disposition says high-school-only, differing from May recommendation. Final board/appeal order not located.", "sources": [ "lubbock-minutes", "lubbock-register", "lubbock-appeal" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-court", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "A Court of Wings and Ruin", "author": "Sarah J. Maas", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee recommendation", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "May 13, 2026: remove from all libraries", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "No final decision located", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-05-13", "dateBasis": "Council recommendation date", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Register describes removal of this and two later series titles under a board-action heading, but does not supply the vote/date. Recommendation is independently documented; final order not located.", "sources": [ "lubbock-minutes", "lubbock-register" ] }, { "id": "lubbock-bible", "districtId": "lubbock-isd", "title": "The Bible", "author": "Multiple / not specified in register", "challenger": "Not located", "challengeReason": "Not stated in reviewed register", "campuses": "Not specified", "grades": "Not specified", "stage": "Committee recommendation", "challengeDate": "Not located", "administrativeReview": "Not located", "committeeRecommendation": "May 13, 2026: retain in school libraries", "boardAction": "Not located", "boardVote": "Not located", "boardDate": "Not located", "catalogStatus": "Current campus-level holdings not independently verified", "outcome": "No final decision located", "currentOutcome": "Unknown", "eventDate": "2026-05-13", "dateBasis": "Council recommendation date", "latestSourceDate": "Undated", "lastVerified": "2026-10-09", "notes": "Register says keep at all campuses, but a dated final board order was not located.", "sources": [ "lubbock-minutes", "lubbock-register" ] } ], "fieldNotes": { "county": "Administrative-center county; not an exhaustive boundary list", "outcome": "Last documented action, not necessarily current holdings", "currentOutcome": "Latest public status evidence; unknown if not established", "eventDate": "Day or month precision; see dateBasis", "baseline": "2026-10-09" } }